Insurance Broker Vs Agent: What's The Difference?

Have you ever wondered what the difference is between an agent and broker?

FirstQuote Health Staff
Published on
February 13, 2023
Last Updated on
May 16, 2023
Insurance Broker Vs Agent: What's The Difference?

Insurance agents and brokers play an important role in helping individuals and businesses obtain the coverage they need. Understanding the differences between these two types of professionals is essential for anyone considering purchasing insurance. This article will provide an overview of what makes agents and brokers unique, the range of services they offer and the advantages of working with them. It will also discuss why it’s important to understand the differences before making a decision on which path to take.

In the search for an affordable health insurance plan, there are many factors to consider. Working with a health insurance agent or a health insurance broker is one such consideration. Is there a difference between a broker and an agent? If so how does that impact the search for a health insurance plan? This article explains everything you need to know about obtaining health insurance through an agent or a broker.

Insurance Broker Vs Agent

Insurance agents and brokers both provide clients with advice and services, but there are some key differences between the two that set them apart. Insurance agents work exclusively for one insurance provider or a small number of them, while brokers work with a wider range of carriers, providing a variety of products to their clients. They are both licensed in the state they operate in, typically completing similar training and examinations to demonstrate their knowledge of the industry. Additionally, both offer advice on finding appropriate coverage for the individual or business requirements of their clients. However, it is important to note that insurance brokers have a fiduciary relationship with their clients and must always put their interests first.

While agents are typically employees of an insurance company who only offer one insurance provider’s policies, brokers can shop around different companies and provide more flexibility with rates and options. Brokers may also be able to build relationships with multiple carriers so that they can access special deals or discounts that may not be available to the general public.

What Is an Insurance Agent?

Insurance agents are professional agents who represent specific insurance companies, such as Allstate or State Farm. These agents help customers get the coverage they need, provide advice on what type of policies are available, fill out paperwork and manage claims. Working with an insurance agent provides a personal connection and allows you to get answers to any questions you may have. The best insurance agents have experience in the industry and are knowledgeable about various products, so they can give you accurate information regarding premiums and coverages.

Health insurance agents, or representatives, can represent one insurance company or several different ones. Those who represent one company are considered captive while those who represent multiple companies are independent. They cannot charge any fees to you personally. The compensation they receive is through their commissions and/or a salary with commissions. The health insurance quotes they give are in line with those offered by the company

Representatives who sell insurance products on a company’s behalf must be appointed to do so. The appointment is an agreement between the agency and the insurer. It lists the products that the agency can sell as well as the commission paid out for each product. It also states that the agency has the ability to confirm or bind the policy. Not every policy is able to be bound through an agency though.

There are different types of insurance agents:

  • Captive agents are employees of an insurance company and only offer the products of that specific insurer. They may be specialized in certain types of policies such as life, health, or auto insurance, or they may offer a variety of policies. Independent insurance agents are not employed by one particular insurer and can provide quotes from several different companies.
  • Independent insurance agents will search for the best deal for their clients based on their unique needs and goals. Independent agents can also specialize in specific types of coverage and will often access many more markets than captives.

What is an Insureon?

Insureon is an online platform providing small businesses with access to a range of commercial insurance policies from multiple providers. Insureon simplifies the purchase process for business owners by allowing them to easily compare quotes, identify coverage gaps and buy the right policy for their needs all in one place. The platform provides helpful guides and resources such as FAQs, customer reviews, and articles on common topics to help business owners understand the ins and outs of commercial insurance. Insureon also has a team of experienced agents available to answer any questions that may arise during the buying process.

It is important to note that receiving health insurance quotes does not equal coverage. It’s just a quote.

What is an insurance broker?

Since healthcare intermediaries or intermediaries represent the buyers of insurance, their interest is in finding the best insurance plan for an individual’s healthcare needs. Unlike a representative, an insurance intermediary does not have an appointment or contract with insurance companies. They still receive commissions just like representatives do. Every insurance policy has paid commission fees built into them so the insurance intermediary will receive those.

A health insurance broker is a professional who specializes in finding the best health insurance policy for their clients. The broker will take into account their client’s budget, lifestyle, and medical needs, then compare quotes from different insurers to identify the most suitable plan. Health insurance brokers can provide valuable assistance by offering expert advice and helping to negotiate discounts or lower rates with insurance companies. They can also provide guidance on choosing supplemental policies such as dental, vision, disability and long-term care insurance to ensure that a client has comprehensive coverage.

There are different types of insurance brokers:

  • Independent brokers operate independently and may or may not be affiliated with any particular insurer.
  • Specialized brokers specialize in specific types of insurance such as health or life, while large firms have a more comprehensive product offering that covers many aspects of personal lines insurance from property to casualty.

What Are The Key Differences Between An Insurance Agent and A Broker?

The main difference between an insurance agent and a broker lies in the fees, variety of insurance plans, and who they represent. Insurance agents are typically employees of an insurance company and only offer their products as well as those of their affiliates. They are also compensated on commission. On the other hand, brokers may be independent or employed by large firms, allowing them to shop around for better rates and offer a greater variety of coverage options than agents. Additionally, brokers are typically not paid on commission but rather receive a fee for services rendered. Furthermore, while type agents represent the interests of one insurer, brokers act as intermediaries between insurers and customers, helping to ensure that the most favorable deal is obtained for their clients.

Insurance Agent

  • Fees: Commission
  • Variety: Limited
  • Representation: Insurer Interests
  • Pros: Specialization in one type of insurance
  • Cons: Limited variety of coverage options, dependent on insurer’s fees and commissions

Insurance Broker

  • Fees: Fee for Services
  • Variety: Wider Range
  • Representation: Client Interests
  • Pros: Can shop around for better rates, wider range of coverage options available
  • Cons: Costs may be higher due to fees for services rendered

Is A Health Insurance Agent Or Broker Right For Me?

Going to an insurance representative or an insurance intermediary depends on your health insurance needs and your personal needs. If you already know which insurance company or companies you want to buy from, a captured or independent agency may be the right fit.

Insurance intermediaries are an excellent option for those who need certain kinds of coverage because of their health or if they’ve run into issues with insurance claims or billing before. If this is the first time you’re buying insurance, they are a good option as well. Since they are knowledgeable about insurance and each of the carriers, they will walk you through your options and let you know what you need to be aware of.

Deciding if an insurance broker or agent is right for you largely depends on your needs. If you’re looking for specific coverage or need expert guidance, then working with a professional may be the best option. Brokers often have access to multiple companies and can compare policies to ensure that you find coverage that fits your requirements and budget. Additionally, agents are knowledgeable about the various options available, so they can provide customized advice and resources to help you make an informed decision. Ultimately, it’s important to do your research and shop around before deciding which type of insurance agent is right for you.

The prospect of finding affordable healthcare insurance is a daunting task when done on your own. That is why finding a qualified representative or intermediary is essential in the process. Both will help you find an affordable plan for your needs. Choosing a representative or an intermediary will ultimately depend on what your personal situation is if you’ve gone through the process of buying insurance in the past and if you have any health issues that play a role in your decision.  Ultimately, the choice should come down to determining which party offers the most value while still fitting within one’s budget.

Bottom Line

Making a decision between an insurance agent and broker can be difficult. It is important to take into account which services are offered, payment methods, representation levels and cost of each. FirstQuote Health provides quotes from different providers so you can compare and find the best option for your needs. With FirstQuote Health’s expertise in the insurance industry, it is easy to get the coverage you need at an affordable price.

Popular Articles

Find Health Insurance Quotes in Under 5 Minutes

Simply enter your zip code to find health plans in your area

Redirecting, please wait...
There appears to be an error. Please submit a valid ZIP code.