Affordable Care Act Pros and Cons

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) has the potential to significantly impact individuals, families, and businesses. Want to know the pros and cons of ACA? Check out this guide.

FirstQuote Health Staff
Published on
February 22, 2023
Last Updated on
May 16, 2023
Affordable Care Act Pros and Cons

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) was passed in 2010 and is one of the most significant pieces of healthcare reform in the US. As a result, it has faced an ongoing political battle over the years. It’s important to understand both its pros and cons before drawing conclusions on its impact and effectiveness. Knowing the ACA’s pros and cons can help you determine what is best for you and your family when making health care decisions, as well as give insight into how current and future healthcare legislation may affect you.

The Affordable Care Act has had a far-reaching impact on healthcare in the US. Millions of people now have access to coverage that they didn’t previously, with an estimated 15 million adults gaining insurance through the ACA’s Medicaid expansion alone. It has also increased the quality of care by requiring insurers to cover 10 essential health benefits, including preventive services and mental health services. The ACA has generally been effective at making care more affordable, with premiums going down for many people and financial assistance available to those who need it. Overall, it has been successful in providing greater access to healthcare for Americans and improving their overall health and well-being.

According to the Department of Health and Human Services, the ACA has increased access to health coverage for millions of Americans by expanding Medicaid eligibility and providing financial assistance to help people purchase private insurance through the Health Insurance Marketplace. As of 2019, an estimated 20 million people have gained health coverage due to the ACA.

What is Affordable Care Act?

The Affordable Care Act (ACA), also known as Obamacare, is a comprehensive health care reform law enacted in the United States in 2010. The ACA was designed with the goal of providing access to affordable health care for all Americans. The law requires insurers to cover essential services such as preventive care and mental health services, in addition to providing access to quality, affordable health insurance. The ACA also requires that insurers provide coverage for specific services ranging from hospitalization and prescription drugs to maternity and newborn care and pediatric services. In addition, the ACA sets limits on out-of-pocket expenses so that everyone can get the care they need without having to worry about unaffordable bills. The law also prohibits insurers from refusing coverage or charging higher premiums based on pre-existing conditions. These protections have enabled millions of people in the United States to gain access to health care they may have previously been unable to afford.

The ACA’s 10 essential benefits are designed to make healthcare affordable and accessible for all Americans. These benefits ensure that everyone has access to necessary medical care, including preventive services such as immunizations and cancer screenings, as well as mental health services, vision care and more. Here are the details:

  • Hospitalization: Insurers are required to cover inpatient and outpatient hospital services, as well as necessary care such as lab tests and X-rays.
  • Prescription Drugs: The ACA requires insurers to cover medications prescribed by a doctor, including generic drugs and some over-the-counter drugs when medically necessary.
  • Maternity & Newborn Care: Under the ACA, insurers must provide coverage for pregnant women, labor and delivery services, and newborn care.
  • Pediatric Services: The ACA requires that children have access to preventive care such as yearly checkups, immunizations and dental and vision care.
  • Preventive Care: All plans must include preventive services such as immunizations, cancer screenings and routine physicals at no additional cost to the consumer.
  • Mental Health Services: Insurers must provide coverage for mental health services such as counseling, therapy and treatment of mental illness or substance abuse disorders on par with medical or surgical benefits according to the ACA law.
  • Vision Care: Vision exams are covered under all plans under the ACA; however, eyewear is only covered under certain circumstances such as if a child needs glasses after a vision exam or if an adult has diabetes or glaucoma.
  • Rehabilitative Services: The ACA requires insurers to provide coverage for rehabilitative services designed to help individuals recover from injury or illness such as physical therapy, occupational therapy or speech-language pathology services when ordered by a physician or other certified healthcare professional in accordance with state law requirements.
  • Emergency Room Visit Coverage: Insurers are required to cover emergency room visits without prior authorization so that people can receive lifesaving care immediately when needed regardless of where they live in the United States (in accordance with their plan's network).
  • Essential Health Benefits Package: The Affordable Care Act requires all insurance plans — both individual market plans and employer-based plans — offer essential benefits including maternity care, prescription drug coverage, emotional support services and more depending on your state's regulations.

Affordable Care Act Pros and Cons

Pros of the Affordable Care Act:

Makes Healthcare Accessible

One of the key benefits of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is that it makes access to care more affordable and accessible for all individuals, regardless of their pre-existing conditions. The ACA ensures that individuals have access to essential medical services like hospitalization, prescription drugs, and maternity care. It also provides subsidies to make healthcare more attainable for those who are eligible. Additionally, the ACA invests in preventive care and sets standards for patient safety and quality of care, which improve overall healthcare quality.

No Pre-existing denials

The Affordable Care Act offers many consumer protections which ensure that individuals have coverage they can rely on. These protections include the prohibition of lifetime and annual limits, immunization coverage, the right to appeal insurance company decisions, and banning insurers from denying coverage due to pre-existing conditions. This provides individuals with much needed peace of mind knowing that they have comprehensive healthcare and will not be denied access to care due to their background.

Cost Transparency

The Affordable Care Act also promotes health care cost transparency. This is done by requiring insurers to disclose more information about the true cost of services and allowing individuals to compare prices at different providers. This creates more competition between providers, which helps drive down costs for consumers and allows them to make better informed decisions when choosing a health care provider or plan. Additionally, the ACA promotes access to quality health care regardless of an individual’s ability to pay, which is essential for everyone’s well-being.

ACA Offers Federal Subsidies for Financial Help

One of the greatest benefits of the Affordable Care Act is that it offers federal subsidies to individuals who may not otherwise be able to afford insurance. These subsidies are available to those with incomes below certain levels, and they help make quality health care accessible to a wider range of people. By providing subsidies for individuals and families who meet certain income levels, the ACA helps lower the costs associated with purchasing health insurance on the open market. Additionally, the ACA has helped to expand Medicaid in many states, which enables low-income individuals and families to access health care coverage. This helps to create a more equitable system of health care throughout the United States, which allows everyone to be better insured.  Additionally, the ACA has made Medicaid expansion available in many states, which provides essential coverage for even more Americans who may not have been able to afford it before. This helps ensure quality healthcare for all Americans.

Makes It Easy to Manage Your Healthcare

The Affordable Care Act has also made it easier for an individual to manage their health care, allowing them to choose a doctor, hospital and health plan that works best with their own particular needs. This allows individuals to have more control over their own health care, which can lead to better care decisions as well as improved overall health and quality of life. The ACA also offers additional essential benefits such as mental health services and maternity care for those who need it.

Cons of the Affordable Care Act:

Burden On Employers

One of the main drawbacks of the Affordable Care Act is that it has placed a burden on employers in terms of increased costs and administrative requirements. The ACA has made it mandatory for employers to provide health insurance coverage to their employees, which can add significant costs to businesses who do not already offer such coverage. Additionally, employers are also now required to track employee hours and other related information, which can create an additional administrative burden. As a result, some employers have chosen to reduce their workforce or avoid hiring new employees altogether in order to minimize the associated expenses.

Administrative Burdens

One of the criticisms of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is that it places significant administrative burdens on businesses, insurers, and healthcare providers. The law’s complex regulations, reporting requirements, and eligibility criteria can be difficult to navigate, especially for small businesses and healthcare providers with limited resources. For example, insurers must comply with new rules for medical loss ratios, which require them to spend a certain percentage of premium dollars on healthcare and quality improvement activities. Healthcare providers must also comply with new payment and reporting models, such as the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS), which can be time-consuming and costly to implement. Some critics argue that these administrative burdens can lead to increased costs for businesses and consumers, decreased efficiency in the healthcare system, and reduced access to care in certain areas.

Individual Mandate Penalty

One of the most controversial aspects of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) was the individual mandate penalty, which required most Americans to have health insurance or pay a penalty. Some opponents of the law argued that the mandate represented an infringement on individual freedom, as it required people to purchase a product they may not want or need. The penalty was also seen as regressive, as it could disproportionately impact lower-income individuals who may not be able to afford insurance. The individual mandate penalty was effectively eliminated in 2019, although the ACA still requires insurers to cover people with pre-existing conditions and provides subsidies to help low-income individuals purchase insurance. Despite the elimination of the penalty, some critics argue that the individual mandate was a flawed and unpopular policy that contributed to the ongoing controversy and uncertainty surrounding the ACA.

Political Polarization

he Affordable Care Act (ACA) has been a highly politicized issue since its inception, with supporters and opponents fiercely divided along ideological and partisan lines. This political polarization has contributed to ongoing legal challenges, efforts to repeal or undermine the law, and a lack of consensus on how best to improve the healthcare system. The ACA’s implementation has also been impacted by changes in political power, with some states choosing not to expand Medicaid or enforce certain aspects of the law under Republican leadership. This political uncertainty and instability can create challenges for healthcare providers and consumers, as it can make it difficult to plan for the future and may lead to changes in coverage or benefits. Some argue that the political polarization around the ACA reflects broader divisions in American society and highlights the challenges of achieving meaningful healthcare reform in a deeply divided political environment.

Bottom Line

Learning more about the pros and cons of the ACA is beneficial to understand how it may affect individuals, families and businesses. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) seeks to increase access to health care coverage by providing affordable options, increasing the quality of care, and supporting preventive care. By understanding the benefits and drawbacks of the ACA, individuals can make informed decisions about their health care needs. Additionally, businesses may also benefit from learning more about ACA pros and cons as it can impact employee productivity, recruitment, retention and overall financial health. Understanding both sides of this important law is essential for making wise decisions regarding one’s health care needs.

FirstQuote Health is a platform hat provides health insurance quotes to those looking for coverage. We partner with a wide range of insurance providers to offer customers a variety of options based on their individual needs and budgets.

Popular Articles

Find Health Insurance Quotes in Under 5 Minutes

Simply enter your zip code to find health plans in your area

Redirecting, please wait...
There appears to be an error. Please submit a valid ZIP code.