The Skinny Repeal Fails In Another Blow To The GOP

The Skinny Repeal failed to pass as 3 Senate Republicans voted against the bill. This comes as another blow to the GOP's hopes of healthcare reform.

FirstQuote Health Staff
Published on
February 5, 2019
Last Updated on
May 16, 2023
The Skinny Repeal Fails In Another Blow To The GOP

What Is The Skinny Repeal?

The Skinny Repeal, or Health Care Freedom Act, is the healthcare bill that was voted on in the Senate on July 28, 2017.  This bill ultimately failed to pass with a close margin of 51 votes to 49 votes, which included 3 Senate Republicans who voted against passing the Bill.  

This piece of legislation was referred to as the Skinny Repeal because it didn’t fully repeal the Affordable Care Act, but instead eliminated some of the more controversial policies that the Affordable Care Act brought with it, such as the Individual Mandate.

The Controversy With The Skinny Repeal

One of the biggest contributing factors to why the Skinny Repeal did not pass was its lack of structure.  Even members of the GOP were unsure what policy changes would be included in the health bill.  Whether this was a clean repeal of Obamacare or a modified version remained a mystery until just hours before it was brought to the floor for a vote.   

On the other side of the political spectrum, the DNC felt the Health Care Freedom Act was putting millions of Americans at risk of losing health coverage.  This came after the Congressional Budget Office, or CBO, published their findings noting that upwards of 16 million Americans could find themselves without health insurance.  This moral stance, accompanied by the lack of new policy solidified how the Senate Democrats would cast their votes.

Skinny Repeal Key Changes

Included below are some of the key policies that would have been in effect if the Skinny Repeal was passed by the Senate. 

No More Individual Mandate

The Skinny Repeal would eliminate the Individual Mandate, also known as the Shared Responsibility Payment.  The Individual Mandate is the tax penalty you face under Obamacare if you can afford health insurance but choose not to purchase it.   

The Individual Mandate is vital for Obamacare’s success because it brings more money to health insurance companies from healthy Americans, helping offset the costs for those who are sick or can’t afford to pay for health insurance.  Repealing the individual Mandate would potentially lead to many health insurance carriers leaving the Health Insurance Marketplace, and premiums to jump in price.

Many opponents of the Affordable Care Act see the Individual Mandate as unconstitutional, even though it was upheld as constitutional by the Supreme Court in National Federation of Independent Business vs. Sebelius.  

However, many still feel that the Individual Mandate infringes on individual liberties by requiring someone to purchase a good or service they may not want or need, and eliminates free market competition.   

Loss Of The Employer Mandate

Just like the Individual Mandate, the Employer Mandate would also be eliminated under the Skinny Repeal.  The Employer Mandate was implemented with the Affordable Care Act, and requires businesses with 50 or more employees to offer health insurance plans to full-time employees, or face a penalty.

Proponents of the Skinny Repeal argue that it inhibits job growth and will continue to reduce full-time jobs because full-time employees are too expensive.  On the other side, opponents of the Skinny Bill thinks it’s time for employers to start compensating their employees fairly, and this includes providing health insurance.

Defund Planned Parenthood

The bill would have moved funds from Planned Parenthood services to community health centers. This likely would have reduced the quality and availability of Planned Parenthood's services, which about 2.4 million Americans rely on for sexual and reproductive services each year.  This was a main point of conversation because the left is overwhelmingly against defunding Planned Parenthood.   

While Planned Parenthood would be defunded, the Skinny Repeal would have ramped up spending on community health centers, by increasing funding for these facilities by $422 million.  Community health centers provide services for about 25 million Americans.  

Repeal Without A Replacement

It's important to note that the Skinny Repeal was quite different from a repeal and replace of Obamacare. Rather than replacing Obamacare, the Skinny Repeal would have eliminated some policies which have been touched on in this article, and ultimately reduced Obamacare’s effectiveness. It is unclear whether the GOP would have ultimately passed any sort of replacement for The Affordable Care Act which could have left the healthcare industry scrambling. 

Proponents of the Skinny Repeal

Many conservative legislators felt that this bill would act as a stepping stone towards a more comprehensive repeal and replace of The Affordable Care Act with a freer market-oriented healthcare system. These legislators believe that a freer market-oriented system could improve the quality of healthcare. However, Democrats and some conservatives do not hold this philosophy.

Furthermore, many conservative and democratic legislators feel that The Affordable Care Act has budgetary flaws that would make it unsustainable for the future. These legislators have voiced concerns that the entire health system in the U.S. would collapse if no changes were made to Obamacare.

Why Did The Bill Fail?

As touched upon earlier, the GOP is quite fractured on the issue of healthcare. Some members of the GOP wish to see a clean repeal of The Affordable Act or a new bill that involves very minimal government oversight.   They argue a clean repeal will create a free market that will, in turn, see lower health costs. 

However, other members of the GOP hold a more moderate stance and want some aspects of the ACA to remain in place, and are happy with the Skinny Repeal. Republican legislators have unsuccessfully attempted to come up with a bill that brings these two groups of the GOP together.  

GOP Members Against The Bill

Before the vote took place, Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska already confirmed they would be voting against their party, and against the Skinny Repeal.  While this was a blow to the GOP, all they needed was one more vote to pass the Skinny Repeal.

Senator John McCain of Arizona, who had recently been diagnosed with a brain tumor, made a quick and stunning return to the Senate floor.  McCain was met with overwhelming backlash just days earlier when he voted to bring the Skinny Repeal to a vote, although his immediate speech alluded that he was not in favor of the Skinny Repeal.

As everyone else had cast their vote, the tally remained at 50 votes against, and 49 votes for the new health bill and all it needed was 1 more vote to pass.  When McCain came forward to cast his vote, all eyes were on him as he held a neutral hand up just long enough to build the tension, before giving the final thumbs down that killed the Skinny Repeal.

Is Obamacare Safe Now?

For the moment, there have no changes to the legislation. However, this doesn't mean that changes won't occur in the future. The Republican party is currently divided on how to proceed. Some members of the GOP feel that the party should continue to pursue a complete repeal. Others feel that the party should begin to focus their attention on other issues instead of healthcare.

However, there is one thing that is clear.  President Trump is not done with his attempt to implement a complete repeal of Obamacare, which he made evident with a tweet on July 29, 2017, which read:  

Unless the Republican Senators are total quitters, Repeal & Replace s not dead! Demand another voter before voting on any other bill!

The Senate Better Reconciliation Act

The Senate Better Reconciliation Act was an earlier bill proposed by Senators Lindsey Graham, Dean Heller, and Bill Cassidy. This piece of legislation would have some similarities to the AHCA, but it also would keep some segments of The Affordable Care Act. The proposed bill is called The Senate Better Care Reconciliation Act. This bill is designed as an amendment to The Affordable Care Act.  Here are a few important things to know about it:

Effects On Mandates

Both the individual and employer mandates would be completely eliminated. Furthermore, states would have more of an ability to waive federal insurance mandates. This would give individual states a larger amount of control over the healthcare system. 

While the long-term effects of this change are unknown, it is likely that these changes would reduce healthcare premiums in the short term. This may make it easier for some individuals to get coverage in the short term. Insurers would still have to cover individuals that have pre-existing conditions. 

Changes To The Affordable Care Act Taxes

Some of The Affordable Care Act's taxes would stay in place. For instance, the health insurance premium tax and the pharmaceutical tax would stay in place. These taxes have contributed to rising healthcare costs. 

There is another serious flaw with how this bill would change The Affordable Care Act's tax structure. The money gathered from The Affordable Care Act taxes would be redirected into block grants that are given to states for welfare. 

Effect on Medicaid

Everyone who is able to get Medicaid currently would be able to receive it under this bill, but the coverage would be more limited than it is today. Most aspects of Medicaid would include an individual coverage cap. In addition, there would be cuts to coverage for those with disabilities, families, and seniors. Furthermore, the cuts would increase over time.

The enhanced Medicaid expansion would not occur under this bill. This was set to begin in the year 2020, and it would help to cover a significant number of people.

Popular Articles

Find Health Insurance Quotes in Under 5 Minutes

Simply enter your zip code to find health plans in your area

Redirecting, please wait...
There appears to be an error. Please submit a valid ZIP code.